2 Amys

I have been to 2 Amys many, many times. It has always been consistently amazing and delicious. Their Neapolitan-style pizzas are really special and satisfying and are always fresh with excellent quality ingredients. The restaurant is walk-in only so it can get crowded sometimes, but is fair with everyone who walks in the front door. No reservations accepted. There are small 2 or 4-person tables throughout the dining floor, as well as a bar area towards the back. The vibe is family friendly, and fills with everyone from young kids, to young adults, to older adults looking to enjoy good food and a great wine selection, as well. There are also single-occupancy gender-neutral bathrooms, which I try to take note of when I write restaurant reviews for the safety of trans and non-binary customers and foodies. Parking is street parking, either paid or, oftentimes, you can find a spot in the 2-hr neighborhood nearby. 2 Amys has been around for a while and they've never, to my knowledge, dipped in quality. Service is very busy but friendly. As I mentioned above, you'll be seated when an open table becomes vacant. After that, be ready for a great meal One other thing, tipping is included into every check and additional tips are not accepted. Enjoy your meal :)

A classic. The appetizers are all amazing - deviled eggs, suppli, meatballs. The green sauce that goes with the deviled eggs brings them to another level! We tried the anchovies this time - taste truly of the ocean, paired super well with the fresh cream butter and bread. The pizza is consistently flavorful and delicious, ingredients are super fresh and the crust is crispy and thin. just watch out because its burn your mouth hot. Highlight of the meal is always dessert! The strawberry shortcake is a must try. The cream is light and soft, the strawberries and biscuit are a great accessory. Thanks Amy!

Mixed feelings. This place has been highly recommended for years, and we finally decided to pop in. My husband & stepson got the pizza, and they both said it was a solid 9/10. The crust was slightly undercooked, but overall, they thought it was a good pizza. I thought they had a gf pizza option (my fault), but they don't. The good news was that they had non-pizza options on the menu...the bad news is that they were not very good...especially for the price. The devil eggs tasted like they were pre-made and definitely had a crust on the inside, and the filling was bland and dense. The dish came with a parsley pesto sauce that was delicious and redeemed the dish. The airplane mozzarella was terribly bland, came plain and tasted like it sat on a plane. I've been to Italy too many times to count, and when I saw that, it was flown in, I was super excited!! Complete disappointment and NOT worth $19. The little gem salad was good, and the anchovy dressing was tasty. Eggs in the salad were super overcooked. The service was outstanding. Food came out fast, hot and all staff were on point!

Service is really friendly and quick. No reservations but you can have a drink at the bar whilst you wait for a table. Appetisers and pizzas are both delicious and love the cannoli for dessert.

Fantastic pizza. Great atmosphere. No reservation required. No tip needed. Is this the future of dining??? I certainly hope so. Can’t wait to return for many more! Ordered margharita - since that’s the baseline to judge a good pizza. The crust was crispy, unbelievably thin in the middle, cooked to perfection with a good combination of chew on the edges and snap in the middle. It was flavorful with a good amount of charred bits. The sauce was acidic, bright, and sweet. The daily special pizza was great too. The 2 Amy sausage on it was a highlight -packed with fennel. The pizza was a bit spicy which hit the spot.

Awesome place. Pizza was really good. The dough was pretty much perfect. The Sicilian anchovies were really good as well. Really enjoyed the food. The service was good as well, and line was out the door at 5pm sharp, so super busy.

We love 2Amys. We came here for pie day this year, and as always, they don’t disappoint. The pies are cooked to perfection and very customizable. The almond cake is fantastic. They make their ice cream in house. Do not miss out! The service is also good- helpful and attentive without being overbearing. It’s always crowded because it’s popular, and there’s something fun about eating in a packed place buzzing with energy & full of delightful bites. 10/10 recommend